Are Women Earning More Than Men?

Started by ????????, May 19 06 03:46

Previous topic - Next topic

????????

 By Warren Farrell [span class="mainartdate"]05.12.06,           3:00 PM ET[/span]

[font style="text-transform: uppercase; float: left;"]New York -[/font]When I was on the board of directors for the National Organization for Women in New York City during the 1970s, I led protests against the pay gap. I wore a "59 Cents" pin to reflect my objection to the discrimination I felt was the cause of women earning only 59 cents to each dollar earned by men. Now, since I'm a husband and father, discrimination against women isn't just political, it's personal.  But one question haunted me through the years: If an employer has to pay a man one dollar for the same work a woman would do for 59 cents, why would anyone hire a man? If women do produce more for less, I thought, women who own their own businesses should earn more than male business owners. So I checked. I found that women entrepreneurs earn 50% less than their male counterparts. [/p] It's not that women are less effective or productive--they just have different priorities. A 2001 survey of business owners with M.B.A.s conducted by the Rochester Institute of Technology found that money was the primary motivator for only 29% of women, versus 76% of men. Women prioritized flexibility, fulfillment, autonomy and safety. [/p] After more than a decade of research for my book,  [em] [a href="http://www.warrenfarrell.com/"]Why Men Earn More[/a][/em], I discovered that men and women make 25 work-life choices that actually create a wage gap. Men make decisions that result in their making more money. On the other hand, women make decisions that earn them better lives (e.g., more family and friend time).[/p]But what happens when women make the same lucrative decisions typically made by men? The good news--for women, at least: Women actually earn more. For example, when a male and a female civil engineer both stay with their respective companies for ten years, travel and relocate equally and take the same career risks, the woman ends up making more. And among workers who have never been married and never had children, women earn 117% of what men do. (This factors in education, hours worked and age.) [/p] Without husbands, women have to focus on earning more. They work longer hours, they're willing to relocate and they're more likely to choose higher-paying fields like technology. Without children, men have more liberty to earn less--that is, they are free to pursue more fulfilling and less lucrative careers, like writing or art or teaching social studies. [/p] What about the headlines saying that even when their jobs are the same, men get paid more than women? Isn't that especially true in corporate America? Yes. But according to Catalyst, a nonprofit that advocates for gender equality in the business world, men are nine times more likely to be responsible for bottom-line sales, marketing and finances, not human resources or public relations. [/p] But wait. Don't companies favor men for these greater responsibilities to begin with? Sometimes. Overall, though, track records being equal, whoever is more willing to relocate, travel and work 80-hour weeks receives greater responsibilities. The male corporate model is built on a man's greater willingness to be a slave of sorts--especially once he has to provide for children. [/p] Is there discrimination against women? Yes. There's no denying that the old boys' network is alive and well. But there's also discrimination against men. For example, try getting hired as a male dental hygienist, nursery school teacher or cocktail waiter, or try selling clothing at Wal-Mart Stores. (Even the employees in the men's wear department are 93% women.)[/p] When we focus our binoculars only on discrimination, we miss opportunities available to women, such as the 80 fields (e.g., financial analysis, radiation therapy, statistics and most engineering fields) in which women now earn more than men.[/p] I want my daughters to know that working 44 versus 34 hours per week leads to more than twice the pay. As I took my binoculars off of discrimination against my wife and daughters, I discovered new opportunities in store for them.[/p]    [em]Dr. Warren Farrell is the author of [/em]Why Men Earn More: The Startling Truth Behind the Pay Gap--and What Women Can Do About It  [em]and the international best-sellers [/em]Why Men Are The Way They Are  [em]and[/em] The Myth of Male Power. [em] Dr. Farrell is the only man in the U.S. ever elected three times to the board of directors for the National Organization for Women in New York City.[/em] [/p]    

Lise

Consider the woman who stays at home and looks after her children... if you pay her for all the hours she's given to her family, you  could NEVER afford her salary.

  We're still a long way from being paid the amount we're entitled to but we're getting there.  
Always end the name of your child with a vowel, so that when you yell the name will carry.
Bill Cosby.

Dissident

I'm not going into the larger argument that I think this article and others like it represents.  However, I will point out a place where the author is begging the question.

He cites highly female-dominated jobs like dental hygeinist, cocktail waiting and "selling clothes" at Walmart, saying that it is difficult for a man to be hired in those fields, as males represent such a small percentage of workers in those bottom-of the-ladder jobs.  

Anyone who has worked in retail, as a server or in healthcare knows that his statistics represent an effect rather than a cause:  e.g., he conveniently overlooks the corporate culture of Walmart that was exposed in the successful class-action suit by their female employees, showing that inexperienced male employees were being systematically promoted to management jobs above qualified women.

Remember the late 80s propaganda about how women were more likely to get killed by a terrorist than be married after the age of 25?  That claim was later proven to be totally bogus, and part of an anti-female political/cultural backlash.

All these articles about college girls going for their "MRS" degrees, young mothers "choosing" to drop out of the workforce, women being responsible for more workplace bullying than men are similar.  I can't comment on the first two issues first-hand, but I can assure you that, though I've had my share of objectionable female bosses, the worst workplace bullying and harrassment I've ever had to deal with came from men.  Male bullying goes largely unreported, and though I understand that legitimate bullying claims against women deserve punishment, I wonder if a large percentage of them come from men with major attitude problems whose egos can't support taking orders from a female.
 
fenec rawks!